« Back to February 2015 Competition
Exam
Old surgeon is "playing" with young intern on exam.
P.S. The body is not a real patient. It's just a friend of the surgeon playing his role.
Comments
(Commenting only available during the rating period)
Ben Hopper
Really good animation. Not sure if the acting matches the dialogue, but it was fun to watch.
Jerry Graham
Question - are you supposed to see the arm going through the body when he reaches in?
David Krein
Okay, I have no idea what is happening in this, but I just laughed a lot. My biggest wonder is if the reaching through and you can see his arm is intentional and then he shuts off the machine and is him just trolling the other guy, whose reactions were awesome by the way. It doesn't fit the audio at all, but as a parody of the audio I really enjoyed it.
Maysa Bogheiri
I found the concept Very interesting and refreshing. But the animation can benefit from more subtle acting at the beginning.
James Trimm
there is some very good animation there- couldn't help but laugh when he reaches in - his stomach must go down to the floor?:)
Seriuosly though, that is really good animation at the end (and beginning too), but had to watch a second time for the beginning.... which has equally good animation, but there perhaps is just a bit too much action to register first off - also camera focuses on other guy at very beginning which for me is a bit off-putting?
Sai Srikanth Charepalli
That's hillarious. Good job.
Robert Huffmon
Other than seeing his arm go through the table, this is great!
Matt
hehe. a little to animated for the audio
Nishith
great work!!!
Steve Schwartz
from frame 50-100, everything happens way too fast, not sure what it is the "soon to be dead" guy is doing. Also, his arm shows up as he's digging through his chest. Everything else looks pretty good!
Sandra Tapia
Fantastic job with idea. 159-203, I'm confused, where is the main character getting the organ from? From inside the corpse?
Oliver Pedersen
The animation technically was not bad but I feel like that the intensity of the acting/performance did not match the calmness of the sound byte that much
Amartya Mukherji
Nice animation no doubt. In-fact without audio it looked really good. But the intensity and energy of the dialogue is not matching. You could have restricted the timing and spacing of your poses. Proper controlled, subtle and limited actions were needed.
[user]
Awesome!
MartyB
Good shot.I would fix the eyes of the second character on F22 or even delete that camera. I don't think you even need it, it goes by so quick
ben malberg
Man this is really nice. I love the characters, it's very entertaining to watch. The guy fainting was a great touch. I think things are happening too fast for me to follow especially the first time watching it. Around f70-f110 the timing of everything happens so quickly. I'm not sure if it was intentional or not but seeing his hand penetrate through the patient's back didn't help the acting, and poses which you beautifully set up. I especially loved the other doctor, his reactions were very funny and I lol'd a couple of times. Mainly, please so this down, or due to time constraints not have everything synced to the audio.
Daniel Boyle
Amazing!





